Live from the Lilith Blog

April 21, 2011 by

Commemorating

It was one week into my family’s trip to Israel, and we lost our camera. Perhaps it was stolen. Most likely it fell out of the bottom of the stroller, while I was digging for sunscreen, or pretzels, or a hat. Perhaps it was the inevitable sacrifice, to appease the gods who watch over those who travel with young children and worry about losing BPA-free bottles and spoons, favorite dolls’ clothing, socks, diaper-bags, not to mention, of course, the children themselves. I noticed the camera was gone when the children were bathed and clean and dressed for the Sabbath. The girls had flower head-bands in their hair and the baby was wearing a vest, the sun was setting over the walls of the old city in Jerusalem, and the air smelled of the exhaust fumes of the last Friday buses, and of jasmine.

What upset me most was losing a week’s worth of pictures. My oldest moaned: “now it’s like we were never here.” I momentarily entertained the thought of buying a new camera, and retracing our steps. My husband suggested that we could leave pages of our photo-album blank; a trip of blind images, wisps of memories trickling ephemeral from between our fingers.

Now, though, that it is Passover, and the leavened excesses of our existence have been burned, for the moment, and, as a people, we are immersed in the preservation of an ancient psychic memory, the loss seems strangely appropriate. It has reminded me to spend some time experiencing, rather than preserving an experience. I have become so accustomed to reflecting while living, that, perhaps, I have cheated myself out of the full joy of being, of living, without trying to figure out how to package, market, preserve that life. My camera, Twitter account, Facebook site, all at once seem like chametz, bloated with self, replete with very me. How appropriate to be without a camera on Passover, to travel, suddenly, lighter, with a different lens. Emptying myself of these vehicles for expression, I find more space to be. I am reminded of a poem by Sir Thomas Browne:

If Thou Could’st Empty All Thyself of Self

If thou could`st empty all thyself of self,
Like to a shell dishabited,
Then might He find thee on the ocean shelf,
And say, `This is not dead`,
And fill thee with Himself instead.

But thou art all replete with very thou
And hast such shrewd activity,
That when He comes, He says, `This is enow
Unto itself – `twere better let it be,
It is so small and full, there is no room for me.`

Avivah Zornberg, in her piece “Then our Mouths Shall be Full of Laughter” in last Monday’s Ha’aretz, writes: “Sometimes we buy souvenirs to forget where we have been; in a sense, a souvenir celebrates the destruction of the memory, but in the guise of its preservation.” The night before we lost the camera, I was looking through the pictures, deleting some, dwelling on others. I remember thinking – how quickly a day becomes a memory; soon this trip will be nothing more than these few pictures, posted, shared, printed, enshrined.

Now, in the space this simple loss has created, we are challenged with experiencing, and, in the future, preserving. We will take our cues from the Seder. We will learn songs, and, when we return, we will sing them. We will deepen relationships, and, upon our return, will continue to nourish them. We will write, and draw, and eat, and play, and, when the day is done, we will wash our dirty feet and sleep under dark skies with sun on our faces. We will commemorate. We will share stories from mouth to mouth, generation to generation, filling in each other’s gaps with laughter as ancient as this land. We will depend on each other, one day, to make meaning of this experience. And, in the meantime, we will live, slightly more free.


  • Randi Brenowitz

    When I was a young woman, a much older friend said that she and her husband had stopped taking a camera when they traveled – trying to experience rather than preserve the trip. I thought they were either nuts or lazy. Twenty-five years later, I totally understand and have stopped taking a camera when I travel…glad you got to learn that lesson so young.

  • http://aquariumofvulcan.blogspot.com/ Kevin Faulkner

    Sorry, but your verse quotation is not by Sir Thomas Browne perhaps another Browne? Unless of course you can refute 15 years of my study of his text and point me to its source in his literary works !

  • Pingback: Link Roundup: Earth Day and Orthodox Women |

  • Helyn Williams

    Why does there always have to be a guy with a know-it-all attitude, who needs to correct stuff even in this most wonderful story . Guy, this is so funny, cause you got the correction, but totally missed the message. Kevin…get with the program. 15 years of studying text and still you don’t get it!

  • maya

    I’m always open to factual corrections – does anyone know the correct author of that poem? My research continues to lead me toward Sir Thomas Browne – would love to know the true author. But also appreciate your re-focus on the point of the piece, Helyn!

  • Sloane Sloawnrivalka

    Thought the poem beautiful even if had to read it a number of times before it sank into my neuronal networking arrays; seem to recall mention of the name of Sir Thomas Browne in my past when read somethings of Sir Osler of United Kingdom was it? or of Canadian fame possibly? It is in my now dismally faint younger years before had some delightful leisure to take time to savour with delight all of the thoughtful comments by Jews who have it all apparently wherever able to go to find out more by patient inquiry.
    – anon, a gur toshav and federal senior delighted to be in the
    community of Canada for a season before go bellyup.

  • http://aquariumofvulcan.blogspot.com/ Kevin Faulkner

    Helen, why does there always have to be a misandrist who resents being corrected even if when that correction is apologetic and true ? There’s no ‘know-it-all attitude’ to a statement which corrects misinformation, it’s called a predilection for truth that’s all.